UC Observer logo
UCObserver on SoundCloud UCObserver on YouTube UCObserver on Facebook UCObserver on Twitter UCObserver's RSS Feeds

Undercutting health care

Most Canadians and their doctors support medicare. But attacks upon it have been constant.

By Dennis Gruending


Vancouver orthopedic surgeon Dr. Brian Day is challenging a law that prohibits doctors from working in both the public and private health-care systems simultaneously — and billing their patients extra while they do so.

Bizarrely, Day — who boxed in his youth — compares himself to the late Muhammad Ali. Like a kind of a freedom fighter, he says he’s going to court not out of self-interest, but rather on behalf of patients on waiting lists.

The basic tenets of medicare, which covers hospital stays and physicians’ services, are that it be tax-financed, publicly administered and equally available to everyone. Day, however, told the National Post: “We in Canada will give the same level of services to a wealthy person as to person who isn’t wealthy, and that doesn’t make sense.” Muhammad Ali he is not.

In fact, it seems that Day has been extra-billing patients for years. According to the B.C. Medical Services Commission audit initiated in 2008 and completed in 2012, Day’s clinic illegally charged patients hundreds of thousands of dollars more for services covered by medicare than is permitted by law. Claiming that the law preventing a doctor from extra-billing patients is unconstitutional, Day filed his challenge in 2009 once the audit began.

In Canada, the fee for physicians’ services is negotiated between the medical profession and agencies of a provincial government. There is nothing to stop a doctor from practicing entirely outside of the public system and billing his or her patients rather than the government. What Day wants, however, is the right to provide services in both the private and public systems, and, of course, extra-bill. In other words, he wants to charge more than the negotiated fees. Then-Health Minister Monique Begin made that illegal in 1983 because she believed it created a financial barrier for the poor and people of modest means.

Day’s critics say that his solution would mean reduced services for patients who don’t have the extra money to jump the queue. Former Saskatchewan Premier Roy Romanow, who led the Royal Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada concluded in 2002 that Canadians cherish their health-care system and see it as a right of citizenship. Most often, it works well, but it’s also in need of improvement and innovation, which Romanow said demands thoughtful reform but not privatization.

Most Canadians and their doctors support medicare, too. But attacks upon it have been constant and led most notably by the Fraser Institute, a Vancouver-based lobby group that also dislikes unions and public schools, and challenges the science of climate change. Some politicians, including former premiers Ralph Klein and Mike Harris, also wanted to undercut medicare, but citizens and voters wouldn’t stand for it. With the political door closed to them, Day and his backers are trying to use the courts for the very same purpose.


Author's photo
Dennis Gruending is an Ottawa-based author, blogger and a former Member of Parliament. His work will appear on the second and fourth Thursday of the month. His Pulpit and Politics blog can be found at www.dennisgruending.ca.
August 2016

The bigots and the foolhardy have their day  

By Dennis Gruending

Racist comments follow the shooting death of a First Nations man in Saskatchewan 


August 2016

Religion and the U.S. election

By Dennis Gruending

There’s no Sermon on the Mount from Trump

June 2016

A peaceable kingdom?

By Dennis Gruending

Celebrate Canadian democracy. But let’s not be complacent.

June 2016

Sowing doubt and muddying the waters

By Dennis Gruending

Climate change deniers continue their political games

June 2016

The TRC Reading Challenge

By Dennis Gruending

Canadians must redeem the past by walking in solidarity with Indigenous peoples

May 2016

Where’s Stephen Harper?

By Dennis Gruending

The former PM may want to avoid being a distraction to Conservatives

April 2016

Bill C-14

By Dennis Gruending

When it comes to medical assistance in dying, churches are one voice among many

April 2016

Truth and Reconciliation

By Dennis Gruending

The shared journey between Indigenous and non-indigenous peoples is a marathon

March 2016

‘Good religion’

By Dennis Gruending

Faith still has a role to play in peacebuilding

March 2016

Jobs versus human rights

By Dennis Gruending

Selling arms to the Saudis creates a ’reasonable risk’ to civilian populations

March 2016

No room for cynicism

By Dennis Gruending

Canada’s first ministers meet to talk climate change

February 2016

Seniors’ strategy

By Dennis Gruending

The CMA’s Demand A Plan campaign was the real winner last election

January 2016

Good neighbours

By Dennis Gruending

Politicians will only do whatever Canadians support — and accept

January 2016

Trudeau’s honeymoon

By Dennis Gruending

Canada’s new prime minister over-promises and under-delivers

December 2015

Promising signs

By Dennis Gruending

There's no magic fix in Paris, but there are hints of hope

November 2015

We cannot turn away

By Dennis Gruending

Welcoming Syrian refugees to Canada is a marathon, not a sprint


November 2015

'Peace cannot be won on the battlefield'

By Dennis Gruending

Peacemaker Ernie Regehr has some advice for Canada's new government

October 2015

Trudeau's 'sunny ways'

By Dennis Gruending

Despite political optimism, there may be some clouds on the horizon

October 2015

Suppressing our better angels

By Dennis Gruending

Racism rears its head in the Canadian election

September 2015

Precious democracy

By Dennis Gruending

Voices-Voix confronts Conservatives on stifling Canadians' fundamental right

September 2015

Syrian refugee crisis

By Dennis Gruending

What you can do to help

August 2015

Election 2015

By Dennis Gruending

Faith groups have lots of questions for candidates this go around

August 2015

Paltry returns

By Dennis Gruending

Public spending on sports palaces is just bad economics

July 2015

Pontiff’s ‘grand message’

By Dennis Gruending

Pope Francis calls for spiritual and environmental revolution

June 2015

Happy warriors

By Dennis Gruending

Order of Canada recipients call for the elimination of nukes

June 2015

Truth, reconciliation and Canadian churches

By Dennis Gruending

Despite having been a part of the 130-year story of residential schools, churches have a history of protecting and promoting Indigenous rights. That's something to build on after the TRC's findings.

May 2015

TRC comes to an end

By Dennis Gruending

Still, residential schools statistics are hard for many Canadians to forget

May 2015

Justice Tour 2015

By Dennis Gruending

Churches focus on climate change and ending poverty

April 2015

Dignity for all

By Dennis Gruending

No anti-poverty measures are to be found in the federal budget

Promotional Image

Editorials

David Wilson%

Observations

by David Wilson

This bad-news planet

Promotional Image

Video

Merle Robillard

ObserverDocs: Out of Syria

by Observer Staff

For nearly half a century, the Elnabrees family has fled one war after another: Palestine, Kuwait, Iraq and, more recently, Syria. This year, they arrived as refugees in Canada, sponsored by relatives and United churches. Ayman Elshafiy, his wife, Sonia, their two daughters, his sister and mother, were among them.

Promotional Image

Faith

September 2016

Rainbow Muslims

by Davide Mastracci

More than half of Canadian Muslims believe it’s impossible to be an observant Muslim while living openly in an LGBT relationship. El-Farouk Khaki and Troy Jackson, co-founders of Unity Mosque, are proving there is another way.

Essays

September 2016

Home

by Various Writers

They say there’s no place like it. Five recently uprooted writers reflect on the true meaning of the word.

Society

June 2016

All the lonely people

by André Picard

An estimated six million Canadians live in isolation. Social researchers are now calling it a hidden epidemic.

Society

May 2016

Are vegans right?

by David Macfarlane

The writer is in the midst of a radical six-month change of diet. He’s discovering that no cheeseburger tastes as good as being ethical feels.

Faith

March 2016

The Walrus Talks Spirituality

by Observer Staff

Promotional Image