With the Trudeau government set to legalize marijuana, it’s time for a truly sober look at the pros and cons of pot
By Pieta Woolley
It’s lunchtime at Vancouver’s marijuana-friendly New Amsterdam Cafe. But no one is eating lunch. Instead, the customers — entirely male, it should be noted — have gathered around the long counter at the back. They’re vaping: smoking pot though an e-cigarette-like device, to keep the dense, weedy aroma at bay.
They’re a quiet bunch, enjoying their herb and watching post-season baseball on TV. A few let out a lethargic cheer when the Blue Jays win a midday game.
Behind another counter, general manager Mike Dobbs shows off a well-lit selection of striped and swirly blown-glass bongs, vapes, pipes and other paraphernalia, as colourful and shiny as candy. Dobbs, a former corporate salesperson, believes this is the new normal. And why not? For the 30-or-so regulars and a few drop-ins here, smoking marijuana is a peaceful, social activity.
“Hopefully, we’ll have a New Amsterdam in every city across Canada,” Dobbs says, mentioning that the café, which is attached to Cannabis Culture magazine upstairs and the British Columbia Marijuana Party headquarters, has developed a complicated détente with the Vancouver Police Department over the last 15 years. “But no one wants to put money into a store that will get shut down by the cops.”
This dimly lit bar is Canada’s epicentre for the fight for legal marijuana — a fight that, with the election of Justin Trudeau’s Liberals, has probably been won. Former prime minister Stephen Harper stood strong against recreational drugs throughout his almost decade-long term. Trudeau, however, ran on the polar opposite platform: “To ensure that we keep marijuana out of the hands of children, and the profits out of the hands of criminals, we will legalize, regulate, and restrict access to marijuana.”
Legalizing marijuana would put Canada in the same camp as four American states: Washington, Oregon, Colorado and Alaska. It would end a 92-year-old prohibition — laws that were in part popularized by the United Church’s founding denominations through the temperance movement. At that time, sobriety was about social justice — avoiding family violence and poverty. Drugs, including marijuana and cocaine, were lumped in with alcohol as sources of social ills.
In 1922, for example, Emily Murphy wrote The Black Candle, a temperance tome that included a chapter about “marahuana.” Murphy, one of the “Famous Five” who fought for women to be included as “persons” under the law, quotes a police chief who says marijuana users “become raving maniacs and are liable to kill or indulge in any form of violence to other persons, using the most savage methods of cruelty without, as said before, any sense of moral responsibility.” The next year, marijuana was outlawed in Canada under the Opium and Narcotic Drug Act.
And so, here we are.
The United Church has made no statements concerning marijuana specifically, though on the books, the church is still pro-abstinence regarding alcohol (while acknowledging moderate use). Research, however, suggests Murphy was way off in her assessment of marijuana’s evils. Long-term regular use, according to Health Canada, can cause memory loss, a decrease in mental ability including decision-making and concentration, and may trigger schizophrenia. But violence? No.
In fact, legalizing the drug may decrease gang violence in Canada, according to Stop the Violence BC, a coalition that includes Ross Lander, a former B.C. Supreme Court judge. Marijuana also helps addicts of violence-triggering drugs such as crystal meth to exit their habits gently, according to a 2011 study by the Centre for Addictions Research of BC.
While some doctors support marijuana use for various ailments, the College of Family Physicians of Canada’s policy for prescribing the drug extends only to chronic pain and anxiety, “pending the development of formal guidelines.” The Canadian Medical Association, however, “still believes there is insufficient scientific evidence available to support the use of marijuana for clinical purposes.”
So is pot prohibition just something mainline Protestants were fundamentally wrong about? Is all this sobriety denying us something elemental and delightful? Or is there an unknown lurking in the post-legalization future that should give abstinence-advocating denominations pause?
“Hey, man. Would you like to take a rocket ship right into the heart of God?” Well, who wouldn’t?
Seven years ago, Martin Ball picked up a vaporizer during a ceremony at Oregon’s Temple of Awakening Divinity. Before he had even finished inhaling, “I immediately knew this is it,” says the now-adjunct professor of religious studies at Southern Oregon University.
“This explosion of pure love erupted in my heart. . . . Within seconds, I was saying, ‘Thank you, God! Thank you, God!’ For 40 minutes, I was laughing and crying. . . . It was direct and immediate. I was encountering a self-aware being and an infinite source of love. Oh my God. This is what I had been looking for my entire life, but I didn’t know it was there. It completely transformed my life.”
Before anyone gets too excited, Ball wasn’t smoking pot. He had just tried an extract of the South American Anadenanthera peregrina seeds. The experience sent the former spiritual seeker and sort-of Buddhist on a new academic adventure.
Now, he teaches about drug use in religion. In October, Ball presented at the fifth annual Spirit Plant Medicine Conference at the University of British Columbia, alongside noted Canadian doctor Gabor Maté, who spoke about the psychedelic experience.
Substance-aided spirituality may be trendy in contemporary North America, but mind-altering plant substances have been a part of religious practice since ancient times, Ball says, citing Hinduism, Sufism, some First Nations faith practices and even Jesus-era Judaism as examples.
Cannabis was probably in the anointing oils of the Old and New Testaments, he says, referring to an ingredient called kaneh-bosm in the ancient Hebrew. It’s mentioned in the books of Exodus, Song of Songs, Isaiah, Jeremiah and Ezekiel. Many scholars, including etymologists, linguists, anthropologists and botanists, agree the substance refers to cannabis.
These days, drugs enhance prayer and meditation in Rastafarianism, the Brazilian Santo Daime church (a blend of Catholicism and Indigenous shamanism), the United Church of Cannabis (an actual church in Indiana), the Christian Church of Marijuana in Cochrane, Alta., and Toronto’s Church of the Universe, as well as among the spiritual-but-not-religious set. Mind-altering substances are not evil, Ball argues. They’re spiritual tools.
“The focus of American Protestantism is on worship and obedience and punishment,” he says. “It’s like people are standing around, banging their heads against the wall wondering why God won’t talk to them, why they’re suffering. They think [by resisting drugs] they’re doing something they need to do. I just want to tell them, ‘Change your perspective. Stop banging your head.’”
Ball isn’t asking Christians to ride the rocket ship. Rather, he wants them to recognize that sister faiths use marijuana and other plant-based drugs. For the sake of religious freedom and equality, he wishes Christians would join the fight for legalization or decriminalization (fines, rather than jail time for possession of small amounts of pot) — or at least advocate for religious exemptions.
Marc Emery, Canada’s “Prince of Pot” and the founder of the New
Amsterdam Cafe, would also like the church onside. He says he’s been
jailed 23 times in Canada on marijuana-related charges, and has been
held or jailed in six American states. You can buy “Free Marc Emery”
T-shirts at the café.
Yes, he’s a provocateur. But he’s far from
alone in prison. In Canada, he says, more than two million marijuana
arrests have been made in the past 45 years. Of those, about half
resulted in convictions, and hundreds of thousands of people have spent
time in jail because of marijuana. According to Statistics Canada,
marijuana still accounts for more drug offences in this country than any
other illegal substance.
Emery thinks that’s something
Christians should care about. “Canadian churches have been mostly silent
on marijuana. . . . They see it as a moral failing.” But pot is
harmless, he says. When he takes too much, as he has done many times
over the past 30 years, he says he simply falls asleep.
Church Council on Justice and Corrections, of which the United Church is
a member, hasn’t spoken out on marijuana, according to education
manager Kathryn Bliss. In the 1970s, this was the Christian coalition
that helped shut down Canada’s death penalty. “We’ve always been on the
forefront of pushing for evidence-based policy,” says Bliss, declining
to comment directly on marijuana. “We want to know: What will increase
community safety? What will prevent future crimes? It usually doesn’t
mean putting people in jail and leaving them there.”
Murphy got it wrong on marijuana’s connection to violence, pot is
associated with other ills. Research indicates that in large quantities
over time, marijuana can trigger anxiety and depression and, among
teens, undermine scholastic achievement. The average age Canadians try
pot for the first time is 16, according to 2013 statistics from the
Canadian Centre on Substance Abuse.
A recent study reveals that
two U.S. states where cannabis is newly legal have seen a dramatic
increase in the relationship between fatal car accidents and marijuana.
In Washington, 12 percent of drivers involved in fatal crashes tested
positive for marijuana use, up from six percent before legalization. In
Colorado, the number jumped to 19 percent from 10 percent.
you don’t need to look south for a sample of users. About 2.3 million
Canadians say they use marijuana regularly, according to a University of
Ottawa estimate. A Forum Research poll last month suggested pot use
would increase by 10 percent if it were legal. I asked my Facebook
network for stories about how pot has affected their lives already. This
anecdotal survey revealed a range of complex experiences.
Mike (all of these names have been changed), who grew up a United Church
kid in small-town Ontario, getting high as a teenager and watching the
1982 cult movie Pink Floyd The Wall. After his father died of cancer, he started smoking every day, up to six times a day.
says he lost a decade of his life. “I could function daily but had no
other motivation to do anything other than work enough to buy food and
drugs and entertainment.” He now suffers from paranoia and depression,
which he associates with his years of heavy use. Mike doesn’t think the
drug should be legalized.
On Haida Gwaii in north coastal B.C.,
Jennifer makes herself a batch of pot cookies weekly. She eats one right
before she goes to bed each night to alleviate her chronic Achilles
tendinitis. That’s it. Growing up in suburban Vancouver, she says,
smoking pot was the only thing to do. Because she had a daughter when
she was just 20, she gave up smoking the drug before most of her peers.
She now describes herself as a sober person — the bedtime cookie
“It bothered me that they couldn’t have fun
without it,” she says, pointing out that in B.C., marijuana is
everywhere. At birthday parties she attends with her daughter, the
parents often vape in another room. She isn’t comfortable sending her
daughter to some of her friends’ houses because she knows the parents
toke and drive. It’s uncomfortable. But she does support legalization
In Saskatoon, Anna stopped smoking pot in her 20s;
she’s in her 40s now. But her husband smokes about 10 times a day, on
the back porch. He works from home.
“The first time I saw him
smoke, he said a blessing,” she says. “I thought, this is so New Age and
dumb. He’s not Rastafarian. He’s Jewish. So I rolled my eyes. I didn’t
realize the extent of the habit.”
Since then, they’ve had two
kids — who Anna thinks are learning to associate the smell of pot with
“Daddy.” They’ve fought; she’s delivered ultimatums. It’s an addiction,
she says. So now, she wilfully ignores the marijuana in the house. “From
a logical place, it’s not a big deal,” Anna says, acknowledging that he
is basically the same person when he smokes as when he doesn’t. “It’s
so much less of an issue than alcoholism or hard drugs or sex addiction.
But in my own life, I have a visceral dislike of it.”
Postmodernism. Pleasure. It’s all supposed to intersect and transcend
here, at the New Amsterdam Cafe. High ceilings, exposed brick,
psychedelic murals, T-shirts hung up the walls, each sporting the New
Amsterdam logo, a sexy art deco-inspired design featuring a full-lipped
woman and an elegant halo of cannabis leaves. Everything this café could
possibly do to make its mission seem cool has been done, with flair.
the mainstream media and general population, interest in the
legalization of marijuana is building. Emery compares it to religious
fervour, a sense of coming “liberation.” But there’s little of that at
the New Amsterdam; the laid-back vibe here is about as exciting as an
The final push for legal marijuana is coming from
Canada’s most powerful Catholic: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. He’s
placed mainline Protestants in an awkward position. Falling in line
behind the new prime minister would mark a monumental shift from nearly a
century of advocating abstinence. Standing pat could suggest that
liberal Protestants are out of step with public opinion, although that
has never stopped them before.
“Onward temp’rance soldiers,
bravely onward go,” read the lyrics from an early 1900s songbook of the
Ontario Women’s Christian Temperance Union, set to the tune of Onward, Christian Soldiers.
“We must free our country from this awful foe; Let there be no quarter
given, but, with joy, This destroying demon utterly destroy.”
Has the time come for the church to change its tune?
Pieta Woolley is a writer in Powell River, B.C.
Keep it free!
If you enjoy reading our online stories about ethical living, justice and faith, please make a donation to the Friends of The Observer Fund. Supporting our award-winning journalism will help you and others to continue to access ucobserver.org for free in the months to come.
Founded in 1829, The United Church Observer is the oldest continuously published magazine in North America and the second oldest in the English speaking world. It has won international acclaim for journalistic excellence and garnered more awards for writing than any other Canadian religious publication. Read more...