UC Observer logo
UCObserver on SoundCloud UCObserver on YouTube UCObserver on Facebook UCObserver on Twitter UCObserver's RSS Feeds

The Big Question

Was God ever born?

By John McTavish

Was God ever born? Surely not if we’re thinking of the eternal God of the Bible. How can there ever have been a time when the Creator of time was not alive? Yet there is another sense in which maybe God was born. Isn’t this what the Christmas miracle is celebrating? God identifies with us in Jesus, assumes the flesh and blood of our humanity, and is born among us.

Jesus doesn’t just materialize out of thin air. He comes to us from a woman’s womb having undergone a nine-month gestation. He squeezes through a human pelvis and suckles at a human nipple. He experiences first-hand, personally and intimately, what it means to be a child, an adolescent, an adult.

Yet how can God be a child in Jesus when Jesus himself looks heavenward and calls God “Abba,” “Daddy,” “Father”? This question was eventually answered when the early church began using the model of the Trinity.

Yes, the early Christians said, God is the Creator beyond and above all things. But God is not a prisoner of the Godhead. God is free to come low and be born among us while remaining in the heights of heaven.

This is so because God’s oneness is dynamic. God is able to be both the Father relating to the Son and the Son to the Father in the mysterious unity that is God’s Spirit.

This is all too complicated, say those today who would rather just believe that God is everywhere and leave it at that. God is in you. God is in me. God is in Jesus — only perhaps more so. Deep down, all of us, these people say, are divine.

Such thinking is known as “pantheism,” and it’s not just Christians who are attracted to it. Pantheism is the official position of Hinduism, the oldest living religion in the world. Pantheists can be extremely religious and not have to worry about the complicated theological puzzles that Christianity forces upon us.

Still, pantheism has problems of its own. To say that everything is God and that God is everything surely strains credulity. Was Hitler God? Yes, God did create Hitler. But can we really say that Hitler was divine if only we look deep enough?

John Shelby Spong has commended pantheism as the answer to all our theo-logical problems. “Transcendence stands for the inexhaustible depths of the divine,” the Episcopal bishop and author writes in Why Christianity Must Change or Die. “Human life is capable of entering the infinity of God because the infinity of God can be found in the heart of every human life. The two are not distinct. Humanity and divinity flow together.”

When the 19th-century philosopher Georg Friedrich Hegel said more or less the same thing, Søren Kierkegaard protested. “The fundamental error of modern times lies in the fact that the yawning abyss of quality in the difference between God and man has been removed,” claimed the Danish theologian.

Swiss theologian Karl Barth made the same point in the 20th century when he spoke about “the infinite qualitative distinction between time and eternity.”

And of course the writer of Ecclesiastes said it ages ago: “God is in heaven, and you are upon earth” (5:2).

So if pantheism is not an option, where does that leave us?

I suggest we need to go back to the miracle of the incarnation as understood along Trinitarian lines. God is beyond time and space and yet free to come low and be “born of a woman, born under the law” (Galatians 4:4).

And the Son of God, who is mysteriously one with the Father, is not only born under the law but grows up living under the law. The law of gravity. The laws of human society. The religious laws of his people.

There must have been times when Jesus wanted to break free from these laws. Perhaps he dreamt of turning stones into bread or leaping unharmed from the pinnacle of the temple or taking control of all the kingdoms of the world.

But no, Jesus remained under the law and experienced real human joy and sorrow, real human success and failure, real temptation and frustration — and at the end a real cross with real nails.

Christmas may be a time to stop looking for theological loopholes and simply rejoice in the mind-exploding miracle of the birth of God in the very human child of Bethlehem.

Readers’ advisory: The discussion below is moderated by The UC Observer and facilitated by Intense Debate (ID), an online commentary system. The Observer reserves the right to edit or reject any comment it deems to be inappropriate. Approved comments may be further edited for length, clarity and accuracy, and published in the print edition of the magazine. Please note: readers do not need to sign up with ID to post their comments on ucobserver.org. We require only your user name and e-mail address. Your comments will be posted from Monday to Friday between 9:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. Join the discussion today!


The biggest threat to women in South Africa is their partners

by Kristy Woudstra

An investigation of why one woman is murdered every eight hours by her husband or boyfriend in this African country — and how advocates are trying to stop it.

Promotional Image


Jocelyn Bell%

Observations: My last conversation with Nanny

by Jocelyn Bell

Editor Jocelyn Bell reflects on the power of our final words with loved ones.

Promotional Image


ObserverDocs: Playing by Heart

by Observer Staff

Kara Shaw was born prematurely, became almost totally blind and was later diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder. The 28-year-old also has a unique musical ability, serving as a United Church music director, and performing piano on local and national stages.

Promotional Image


March 2018

Egerton Ryerson: The legacy of a tarnished hero

by Mike Milne

He founded public education in Ontario — and this very magazine — while also promoting residential schools. How should we judge Ryerson today? Some students want his name and image gone.


March 2018

Church organist has been leading worship for 86 years

by Wendy Lowden

And Louise Pelley is still going strong at 98 years old.


February 2018

Pro-choice advocates still at risk despite Ontario’s new abortion law

by Jackie Gillard

Threatening messages spray-painted on their doors and lawns won’t stop those advocating for reproductive rights. If anything, they feel even more determined to help protect those seeking an abortion.


March 2018

The biggest threat to women in South Africa is their partners

by Kristy Woudstra

An investigation of why one woman is murdered every eight hours by her husband or boyfriend in this African country — and how advocates are trying to stop it.


March 2016

The fighter

by Richard Wright

When he was 13 years old, Willie Blackwater stood up to his abuser at a B.C. Indian residential school. His defiance would eventually help change the course of Canadian history.


March 2018

14 writers share their moving final conversations with loved ones

by Various Writers

These stories will make you laugh, cry and rage. Maybe they’ll spark a fond memory. Or perhaps they’ll prompt you to consider the things you need to say now, before it’s too late.

Promotional Image