UC Observer logo
UCObserver on SoundCloud UCObserver on YouTube UCObserver on Facebook UCObserver on Twitter UCObserver's RSS Feeds

The Israel-Palestine report

In search of a third option

By Carolyn Pogue

Everyone makes mistakes. Even churches. I think we are making one right now by wading into the Israel-Palestine question with a recommendation to boycott settlement products. As if.

One proverb I live by isn’t found in the Bible. It comes from Poland, author unknown: “If there are only two options, choose the third.”

Our church has been criticized for taking political stands; I’ve always been proud that we’ve had the guts to do that. We claim that Jesus took stands and would expect his followers to do the same — even if it’s costly. That’s not the issue.

The issue is that we are adding one more negative idea to an already negative situation in Israel and Palestine. The boycott action has been inspired by our work with Christians, Muslims and Jews in Israel and Palestine, who feel frightened and isolated. Nevertheless, we are stumbling into a situation without most of us knowing how it feels to have histories of displacement, exile, genocide. We don’t know how it feels to live surrounded by nations like Iran whose leadership openly state that they want all Jews obliterated. Again.

Decades of peace talks and United Nations experts have failed to bring peace. Maybe they fail because they do what CBC’s Peter Mansbridge did: he asked experts there, “Is peace possible?” But he interviewed the military and government people and ignored the peace experts — the Arabs and Jews who work together for peace.

One of the three-member team who presented the Mideast report at General Council told passionate stories of how terrible life is in the West Bank under the Israeli occupation. Well, living under any occupation is dreadful and humiliating. When I interviewed a member of the Israeli peace group Women in Black for The Observer years ago, she said, “This occupation brutalizes both sides; we don’t want our children conscripted to the army for this. We want an end to it.” They hold weekly silent vigils in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. I wonder how many voting delegates at General Council know about Women in Black, Religions for Peace and other groups.

A third option could be for United Church people to support the Palestinian Israeli Bereaved Families for Peace. No one knows better than the family of a dead child about the need for ending violence and hatred. Members of this grassroots organization meet in person and online, run programs and tell their stories.

A third option could be for United Church people to begin new chapters or support the small Canadian branch of Friends of Wahat al-Salam/Neve Shalom. This village, known in English as Oasis of Peace, was built on land donated by a Christian monastery in the 1970s. Half the citizens are Jews and half are Arabs. They govern themselves, work, play, educate their kids, celebrate each other’s festivals and learn each other’s languages. They run the School for Peace, where people from conflict areas, like Ireland, come to discuss and study peace. There are volunteer opportunities for international visitors. The elementary school is an education in itself: two teachers in every classroom, one Arab and one Jew.

My husband, Very Rev. Bill Phipps, is part of the Canadian Friends of Wahat al-Salam/Neve Shalom, based in Calgary. This spring, they hosted an evening with Dorrit Shippin, a village founder, at a public library. Many came to the talk. People know about violence; there is curiosity about peace.

A third option could be to encourage United Church travellers to the Holy Land to include a visit to Yad Vashem, the Holocaust Memorial in Jerusalem, and to include visits with members of groups like Rabbis for Human Rights.

One vivid image I carry of our visit to the School for Peace is of children entering the playground. They walked beside a peace pole and under a brightly painted rainbow of hope.

There are many third options to a boycott of settlement products (what are they, anyway?) that could have been presented and that would not unravel our church’s work in Bearing Faithful Witness, a bridge-building study of United Church and Jewish relations. Instead, the report has offered yet another negative idea to the mix. We can be more creative than that.

Author's photo
Carolyn Pogue is a longtime Observer contributor. New posts of The Pogue Blog will appear on the first and third Thursday of the month. For more information on Carolyn Pogue, visit www.carolynpogue.ca..
Readers’ advisory: The discussion below is moderated by The UC Observer and facilitated by Intense Debate (ID), an online commentary system. The Observer reserves the right to edit or reject any comment it deems to be inappropriate. Approved comments may be further edited for length, clarity and accuracy, and published in the print edition of the magazine. Please note: readers do not need to sign up with ID to post their comments on ucobserver.org. We require only your user name and e-mail address. Your comments will be posted from Monday to Friday between 9:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. Join the discussion today!


The author is baptized at Central United in Calgary. (Photo courtesy of Al Coe)

Why I got baptized in a United Church at the age of 42

by Jacqueline Mercer-Livesey

"I told myself that I didn’t need to go to church to believe in God. I found peace and the Holy Spirit in the things that surrounded me. But still, there was a nagging sense of something missing."

Promotional Image


Editor/Publisher of The Observer, Jocelyn Bell.

Observations: The rewards of letting go

by Jocelyn Bell

Editor Jocelyn Bell reflects on the upcoming changes for The United Church of Canada, the magazine and in her own life.

Promotional Image


ObserverDocs: Two nurses tackle Vancouver's opioid crisis

Richard Moore is a resident of Vancouver's Downtown Eastside. In this poignant interview, he explains the important work of nurses Evanna Brennan and Susan Giles.

Promotional Image


June 2018

The moment the Pope asked me to pray for him

by Miriam Spies

A United Church minister on the impact of a simple gesture from a powerful man.


July 2018

Best self-care tips for caregivers

by Kate Spencer

Counsellors, teachers and ministers share what it looks like for them.


July 2018

Meet your 2018 moderator nominees

by Mike Milne

Later this month, General Council commissioners will choose the United Church’s next moderator. As of press time, 10 leadership hopefuls had been announced. We asked each of them to sum up their pitch in a tweet.


July 2018

A fond farewell to presbyteries

by Steven Chambers

They will likely be eliminated this year as the United Church restructures. Steven Chambers celebrates the end of an era.


July 2018

Instead of retirement, these two nurses are battling Vancouver's opioid crisis

by Roberta Staley

At age 71 and 65 respectively, Evanna Brennan and Susan Giles embrace their unconventional work in the Downtown Eastside.


June 2018

I hate you, Canada, for teaching people to treat me like this under your name

by Zach Running Coyote

A Cree actor says he blames our country for the racist comments recently directed at him in a McDonald's restaurant.

Promotional Image